Creating a positive office environment within local government departments is no easy task, especially considering the differing challenges officials face. These challenges, ranging from managing budget constraints and policy changes to ensuring effective public service delivery in the face of always changing needs.
Oftentimes, an overlooked aspect of the daily life of a local government official is fostering a workplace where employees feel comfortable, valued and motivated.
Constructive criticism plays a prime role in maintaining positivity within office environments. Unlike micromanagement, which can stifle creativity and employee initiative, constructive criticism focuses on giving feedback that helps employees grow professionally.
Constructive criticism, compared to micromanagement encourages open communication, two way respect, and constant improvement. By setting up a culture where feedback has a constructive and supportive tone, local government officials can empower their team members to excel and innovate!
Table Of Contents: What To Expect
- What is Constructive Criticism?
- The Basics of What Makes Advice Constructive Criticism
- A Deeper Understanding : The Difference Between Constructive and Hurtful Criticism
- How to Encourage Employees to Share Constructive Criticism
What Makes Some Criticism Constructive?
Constructive criticism is feedback given with the intention of helping someone improve. It is focused on the behavior or work performance of a person rather than the person themselves. Due to this, constructive criticism plays a crucial role in a person's professional and personal growth. Here are the key elements of effective constructive criticism:
Overall, constructive criticism is a necessity in personal and professional development. It helps to encourage learning, growth, and improved performance without making anyone feel bad or uneasy. On top of that, it fosters a sense of openness, trust, and continuous improvement within teams or larger organizations. These are important characteristics of a properly functioning local government office, furthering the need for constructive criticism within these groups.
Read our comprehensive guides on Creating A Positive Work Culture In Local Government Offices and Mastering Local Government Employee Performance Reviews here.
The Basics of Giving Constructive Criticism
Within an office setting, there may be a fine line between advice and constructive criticism. Whether it is tone, timing or simply just context, the receiver of constructive criticism may not be able to discern whether the feedback is positive or negative. Here are a few key components of constructive criticism that help to foster growth and improvement.
1. Be Specific
Constructive criticism should be specific rather than create any generalizations. It should focus on particular behaviors, actions or aspects of work that could use some improvement. This specificity helps the recipient better understand what exactly needs to change without making them feel like they are completely missing the mark on a goal or task.
2. Be Clear
The feedback to co-workers or employees should be clear and very understandable. Ambiguity or vague language can lead to confusion or misinterpretation. Clear communication is essential in general, but it especially helps to ensure that the recipient grasps the feedback accurately.
Read GovPilot’s resource on Interdepartmental Government Communication Strategy here.
3. Provide Context
Providing proper context when giving advice or correcting a mistake can help the recipient better understand why exactly the criticism is being given. Contextualization includes referencing specific situations, examples, or criteria that the employee's performance is being evaluated against.
4. Find Balance
An understated aspect of constructive criticism is that it should always be balanced. This means acknowledging what the individual is doing well alongside the areas where you feel they could use some improvement. Balancing feedback will help to maintain morale and motivation while also highlighting areas that need attention. This will ensure that your employee feels like a valued member of the team.
-
- GovTip: Many managers practice “sandwich criticism” or giving a piece of negative feedback between two aspects of a job that the employee is performing well.
Practice with tips from our Local Government Employee Appreciation Strategy here!
5. Speak With Empathy and Respect
It is important to deliver constructive criticism with empathy and respect for the recipient. Recognizing their efforts and intentions helps to demonstrate empathy, and respect. Communication that follows these pillars can help to foster an overall positive relationship built on openness and feedback.
6. Prioritize Timeliness
Timely feedback is always more effective than delayed. This is due to behaviors and actions being addressed while they are still fresh in everyone's memory. Timely constructive criticism helps to make it easier for the recipient to understand and take the proper course of action to resolve it promptly.
GovPilot has tips and tricks to help your office with time management, learn them in our Guide To Time Saving Strategies For Local Government.
7. Make Actionable Suggestions
Alongside pointing out areas of improvement, constructive criticism includes actionable suggestions or recommendations for how your employee or team member can make the change. These suggestions should be realistic and relevant to the situation in order to give your employee or coworker inspiration about how to make improvements for next time.
8. Give Encouragement
Encouraging verbiage is an important element to constructive criticism. It motivates the recipient to take the feedback positively and view it as a growth opportunity rather than a knock on their abilities. Be kind and encourage the employee to try again with their new skills backing them up!
9. Follow-Up!
Creating open dialogue about the criticism can create a sense of transparency, while also tracking progress and providing further support if needed. Keeping an open line of communication reinforces the need for constructive criticism, as well as showing the importance of the employee to the overall goal of the organization.
The Do’s and Don’ts of Receiving Constructive Criticism
Understanding the do’s and don'ts of constructive criticism can help to create a positive environment where both employees and team leaders feel supported, heard, and most importantly, motivated to improve. Here is a list of a few do’s and don'ts when it comes to receiving constructive criticism:
-
Do: Listen Actively
Place a keen eye on the feedback that you are given. It is important to avoid interrupting the person giving you feedback to ensure that you fully understand the points being made before responding. This shows not only respect, but also a clear focus on improving your performance.
-
Don’t: Get Defensive
It can become easy to get defensive of your performance when in a work setting. You may feel that you are doing a better job than you are, and while the effort may be there, you may still have feedback directed towards you.
It is important to avoid reacting defensively or making excuses because your supervisor likely just wants to help you be more efficient and successful. A defensive attitude can halt productive discussion and prevent you from absorbing the constructive criticism as it was intended.
-
Do: Ask Clarifying Questions
Your best reaction in a conversation surrounded by giving you feedback on job performance is a positive one, based on improvement and showing that you care about your job and the work that you do.
One great way to convey this is by asking clarifying questions. Asking for specific examples or a clear explanation can help you avoid making the same mistake in the future. Not only do these types of questions help you hold onto feedback better, it also shows a high level of engagement.
-
Don’t: Avoid the Conversation
When you receive constructive criticism it is imperative that you do not avoid a deeper conversation about it. A positive and strong manager will be sure to give you feedback in a professional and constructive manner, so it is important that you receive it in the same way. To create a healthy relationship with your coworkers, it is important to engage in a constructive conversation to address any concerns or clarify where you may be feeling confused.
Read our guide on Navigating Office Politics From The Top Down here.
Encourage Your Employees to Master Constructive Criticism
Creating an environment where constructive criticism is lifted up in the workplace is a necessity when trying to create a collaborative and growth oriented workplace. When colleagues engage in open, respectful conversation about work performance, it not only improves individual work but helps the team as a whole.
Remember, as a team leader, one of your main jobs should always be to set an example for your colleagues. If you show that constructive feedback is something that you engage in on a regular basis, then many of your coworkers will feel like they are in a safe environment to do so.
Hold office initiatives and meetings in order to give employees a stage to share positive feedback, as well as areas where there can be improvement is a healthy step to a more collaborative office culture. Keep your employees informed on all of the useful benefits and ways to give constructive criticism can help to streamline this type of dialogue happening in your workplace.
Book a consultation with GovPilot to learn more about how we can help!
Read on:
